Best Pizza in New York

Classic New York Pizza since 1975!

Featured

Authentic New York Pizza, Hot and Ready

Sergio's Pizza is four locations strong — serving the same recipe we've made from day one. The same dough and sauce at every location. No shortcuts in 50 years.

Order Now

New York-Style Italian Food, Made Right

Italian food that feels like home. We serve all your favorite classics, made with the time-honored recipes that made us who we are.

View Menu

Our Food

Bring a Slice of NY Tradition to Your Next Event

From corporate meetings and game day watch parties to family celebrations, Sergio’s Pizza brings 50 years of authentic New York tradition straight to your table with plenty of discounted options. We serve up full-sized NY thin-crust pizza, piping hot pasta platters, scratch-made garlic knots, hero sandwiches, and crisp salads—crafted with the same recipes we’ve used since 1975. Flexible pickup and delivery available 7 days a week! Call Your Nearest Location to Order Catering: Malta: (518) 306-4400 Brooklyn: (718) 513-3300 Riverhead: (631) 369-1057

Four Locations Across New York & Beyond

Brooklyn, Riverhead, Ballston Spa, North Carolina, and Utah. Find the one nearest you.

Find a Location

Born in Riverhead, New York

Sergio's Pizza opened in Riverhead on Long Island in 1975. Nearly fifty years in, the same honest New York pie, nothing changed.

Absolutely fabulous pizza, many specialty pizzas by the pie or slice, and friendly and outgoing staff.

Christine R.

Great price point and good pizza. The employees were cool and quick. Also, if you catch them on the right da,y ifeelsel lia ke lounge because of the music.😅

Michael S.

Great pizza place, and I wasn't expecting the mac and cheese bites to be so delicious. The BBQ sauce was my favorite.

James R.

Excellent customer service. The team showed our kids how to flip the dough and made the entire experience so fun. Definitely going back here.

Dawn G.